/
The Why Behind Packaging Design with Rhett Withey
IN CLEAR FOCUS: Hosted by strategy intern Annie Modafferi, Bigeye Art Director Rhett Withey explores the psychology behind packaging design. Discover how creatives balance client visions with consumer behavior to build recognizable, highly enticing products. Rhett explains the crucial differences between designing for physical retail displays versus postage-stamp e-commerce thumbnails, why functionality must match aesthetics, and how brands can avoid trends that quickly become dated.
Episode Transcript
Annie Modafferi: Coming up on this episode of IN CLEAR FOCUS.
Rhett Withey: It has completely ruined my life when it comes to shopping anywhere online or in store. Like I'll stop and look at a package of broccoli and I'm like, I have no I'm not trying to buy broccoli, but look how they package broccoli. This is really interesting.
Annie Modafferi: You're listening to IN CLEAR FOCUS, fresh perspectives on marketing and advertising produced weekly by Bigeye, a strategy-led, full-service creative agency growing brands for clients globally. Hi, I'm your host, Annie Modafferi, Bigeye's fall strategy and insights intern. Thank you for joining us on this special episode. Product design is everywhere. Before we ever pick something up off of the shelf or click add to cart, we've already made a decision about whether it looks appealing, useful, or worth our attention. From color and typography to shape, size, packaging, and even how a product might look in a retail display, there's a lot more strategy behind that first impression than we might realize. So what actually goes on behind the scenes when a product is designed to sell? How do designers balance what a client wants with what they know will appeal to a specific audience? My guest today is Rhett Withey, the art director and backbone of Bigeye's creative team. We're going to talk about the psychology behind packaging, how trends and consumer behavior influence design, and the decisions that go into making a product recognizable, enticing, and ultimately something people want to buy. Hello, Rhett. Welcome to IN CLEAR FOCUS.
Rhett Withey: Hi, Annie.
Annie Modafferi: So, first question for you today is: can you walk us through the design process from start to finish? Once you have the client's vision, what happens between that first conversation and that final product sitting on the shelf?
Rhett Withey: So from start to finish, first it starts with a conversation where the client describes their vision, which is usually three adjectives and a competitor that they secretly want to mimic. So my job is to translate fun, but premium or bold, but approachable into something that actually exists. So from there it's research, like who's buying this, where it's sold, where it's going to be on the shelf, competitors, what we're up against. Then comes concepts for the creative team. We'll make lots of different concepts. Most of them will die quietly in a folder, which is the natural order of things. We'll present a couple of those concepts to the client. The client picks one, sometimes they pick two and ask us to combine them, which is something that keeps me up at night. and then from there we just refine the concepts. Then after that there's lots of rounds of revisions, legal review, someone figures out the barcode doesn't actually fit on the box, then we have printer proofs, then we find out a color that looked great on screen, looks like wet cardboard on the press, and then more proofs, and then eventually finished product on a shelf where nobody looks at it for more than a second and a half.
Annie Modafferi: You know, that's funny because it's almost like the reason that this episode came to me is thinking about when you are a deep thinker, when you're someone, a consumer, you do actually look at those products on the shelf for more than a second and a half, but you do it subconsciously. You don't actually realize you're doing it. But speaking of like the client, what happens when you strongly disagree with their design direction? Like how much of being a designer and being this person for them is actually educating them on, “Hey, this isn't going to work, actually, and you just have to trust me.” And, okay, this is a good idea.
Rhett Withey: Yeah, so I'll disagree politely, but with evidence, and then I will lose gracefully about half the time. I learned a while ago that it's their name on the box, not mine. But a big part of my job is explaining why something works or something doesn't work because I don't like it or this won't read from six feet away are very different arguments, right? And only one of them is really useful. I'd say that being a designer is like 60% design and 40% diplomacy. And the trick, though, is making the client feel like the good idea was their idea. And sometimes it is, but sometimes it's mine. But I'll let them keep it. That way everybody just stays happy.
Annie Modafferi: And what's something consumers probably never think about? The designers spend a lot of time thinking about in that way.
Rhett Withey: So for me, it's definitely everything that's on the back of the package. So like your nutrition panels, the legal copy, warnings, barcodes, recycling symbols, the line that says made in a facility that processes tree nuts. All of that has to fit and be legible and meet regulations and ultimately not look like a ransom note. Also typography, nobody really thinks about type until it's wrong. And then everybody thinks it looks cheap, but they don't really know why. So that's a big part of things that they consumers don't really think about.
Annie Modafferi: When does making something appealing actually make it worse? The functionality or the actual art logo design? What matters more when designing a logo or the actual art on the product? The functionality or the appeal to the audience?
Rhett Withey: So for me, the moment that you can't open it or read it or figure out which of the four nearly identical bottles of shampoo and which is the conditioner, that's the moment, right? Beautiful packaging that hides the product name in silver foil and like white background. It looks nice. It looks great. It looks like art, but it's just not very good packaging. Clients care more. They'll say functionality in the meeting, but then they'll spend an hour talking about how the logo needs to be bigger. Realistically, though, the best clients understand that the art is functional sometimes. And its job is to sell the thing. If it's pretty and nobody buys it, then it's just a really expensive poster.
Annie Modafferi: My favorite example that I thought of when I was doing this is the Angry Orchard or the cardboard beer holder. You're holding on to wet cardboard. And this looks great, but I'm like, there could totally be a different functional way to do this. But I'm sure that the designer was like, “No, this gives it its Angry Orchard. It's supposed to be nature-y,” whatever.
Rhett Withey: If I had a nickel for every time I picked up a soda can box and the handle ripped and all the cans spilled on the floor, I would have like two nickels, but it's enough to realize that this shouldn't be happening so often.
Annie Modafferi: Exactly. Cause it's like, you see the bigger brands are redesigning their logos for holidays for different special events, but you're still using that same cardboard box. That's going to break when I accidentally drop it once.
Rhett Withey: Exactly.
Annie Modafferi: So that's very interesting. And speaking of that, what goes on behind the scenes when deciding what will make a product appealing on a shelf or online? So are you pulling data from other departments about what audience you're targeting or are you following what would look good based on what the client wants? So are you using more of the data or are you using more of their suggestions? So kind of what I said before, but more of an analytical standpoint.
Rhett Withey: So, ideally both. Good clients will come in with research, like who the audience is, what they buy, what the price point they are aiming for is. That shapes a lot of what we'll do. Less ideal clients come in with, “My wife likes purple.” We'll work with what we're given and we'll fill in the gaps with our own research, which mostly just involves like standing in store aisles and taking photos of shelves, like a very boring spy. But yes, I almost always give more suggestions than what I'm asked for. As you could probably tell, like I'll talk. Clients don't always know, though, what they want until they see the things that they don't want. And that's not criticism. That's just how people work.
Annie Modafferi: Now, yeah, especially when it comes to competitor products, you know, they see what they want and what they don't. And in your opinion, what's more important when designing a product? Is it making it recognizable to the brand, like unique, or following the trends that all of these other brands are trying to do? Because we see things we are already used to when we pull it off the shelf. So how do you balance making something stand out with making sure it still feels familiar enough that the consumers will understand it?
Rhett Withey: You want to be different, but not confusing. If you're selling orange juice, you probably still want it to look like orange juice. Nobody wants to gamble on whether the black matte carton with a single lowercase word is juice or an art installation. Categories have shorthand for a reason, right? Like cheese, for instance, cheese comes in yellow and white and blue cheese. But if you think cheese, you think yellow. And so you see mac and cheese boxes that are predominantly yellow. The trick though is respecting the rules enough that people instantly know what it is and then maybe break one or two of those rules so that they remember which one it is. So it's familiar enough to trust, but different enough to notice. And it takes about nine revisions to do that.
Annie Modafferi: Yeah, it is interesting looking at that balance now between the new products that are popping out on the shelves. How do you know when a design trend is actually worth following versus something that's going to look dated in two years? So like the packaging that is like Instagram-able packaging, is that actually something that's a design consideration? Like will this look good on TikTok? Will this look good on Instagram?
Rhett Withey: So a lot of the time the client will present those kinds of things to us. So like if every brand in the category adopts the same look in the past six months, it's going to look dated in like two years. That's kind of the rule. Trends are fine as a seasoning, but it's not the whole meal.
Annie Modafferi: Okay.
Rhett Withey: So if the core brand still works with like, the trendy elements and stuff stripped out, then you're good. But if the trend is the brand, you'll be redesigning soon. So yeah, Instagrammable, that is a consideration now. Packaging, you don't see it just in the store anymore, like on a shelf. It's photoshopped on kitchen counters, or it's floating in an amalgamous way on your social feed. If it's something that looks good in a flat lay with a latte next to it, that's great. That's free advertising. I just am not in love with that's part of the brief now, but here we are.
Annie Modafferi: Let's take a short break. We'll be right back after this message.
![]() | Miya Knights: Hi, I'm Miya Knights, author of "The Future of Shopping: Using Digital, Data and AI to Win with Customers," published by Kogan Page. I've spent more than 25 years covering retail technology as an analyst and an editor, and today I publish Retail Technology magazine. Why people shop hasn't changed much. How retailers and brands meet those needs has. I show how to match data and AI to what your customers are trying to get done, with examples from businesses including LVMH and Walmart. I cover personalization, retail media networks, sustainability, and where the human touch matters the most. As an IN CLEAR FOCUS listener, you can save 25% on "The Future of Shopping" when you order directly from KoganPage.com. Just enter the exclusive code BIGEYE25 at checkout. Shipping is always complimentary for customers in the UK and US. I hope my book helps you earn a place in your customers' next shopping mission. Thank you. |
Annie Modafferi: Welcome back. I'm Annie Modafferi, Bigeye's Fall Strategy and Insights Intern, and I'm talking with Rhett Withey, Bigeye Advertising Agency's Art Director. Working in somewhere like a grocery store or working in retail, I always look at displays and think about them building it and thinking, “Oh, I wonder how they decided to put this product with this?” So do you ever think about, like, if a client comes to you and this product is maybe supposed to go to a major retailer, do you ever think about displays? If this product were to make it into major retailers, are you ever taking it into account how something could be marketed around that item, the more retail side of it all?
Rhett Withey: Yeah, constantly. We're constantly thinking about like when we're designing the packaging, like “How's this going to live on the shelf?” Cause products, they don't live alone, right? They're stacked up, they're lined up in rows, shoved into end caps, crammed in next to the competitors, right? So a lot of the packaging is designed to create like a block on a shelf, meaning like when you line up 10 of them, they'll form like a bigger visual unit that grabs your attention. That's why like a lot of beer companies will make five different types of beer just so they could take up all that shelf space and just have their name repeated a whole bunch of times. So like shelf-ready trays, display boxes, how the front panel reads when it's facing out versus turned sideways, all of that, all these things get considered. You're not designing just like one box or one bottle. You're designing a wall and hoping that the stalker at five o'clock in the morning sets it up the correct way.
Annie Modafferi: And if they don't, then you've considered it.
Rhett Withey: So yeah, it's been in the check Mark of our to-do list of didn't, did we think about this?
Annie Modafferi: Yeah, that's really interesting because you never think about that. If you see a can of Celsius, it could be turned to the side. But I think if you were to pass by it every day at a grocery store, you're still going to know that it's a Celsius even without seeing it on the front. So now let's talk about e-commerce- instead of just being in the retail space like physically. Is there a difference between designing something that looks good in person versus something that looks good in an Amazon listing?
Rhett Withey: Yeah, very. So in person, we have the ability to pick it up. We can feel the texture. We can read that side panel. We can see that it's processed in a facility that uses tree nuts. We can appreciate the embossing that someone fought really hard to get into the budget. But on Amazon, it's a thumbnail the size of a postage stamp next to 40 other postage stamps. And all that subtle detail disappears. So the logo needs to be bigger. Contrast needs to be higher. Product name needs to be readable at like the size of a fingernail. A lot of brands now design with the thumbnail in that mindset first, which that's a little depressing to say out loud, but it's very accurate.
Annie Modafferi: Yeah. Just to follow up to that, do you think that brands nowadays, I mean, it's easier to get your products online for sure. Like when you publish a book, it's two seconds easier to get it onto Kindle Direct Publishing than to get it in Barnes and Noble. So a lot of these brands are starting off with their online shops and everything like that. So are a lot of them really only- from what you've experienced, considering what will look good online- and not really even thinking about if it could make it into a retailer? Even if it is one of their goals. It's like a step-by-step, “Let's not think ahead of ourselves" type of thing.
Rhett Withey: Yeah, kind of. I mean, we've just recently had a couple of clients that are online first, that the main thing they wanted us to tackle was just the front of the packaging. And they really didn't have many opinions about the top or the side or the bottom or anything like that. They were just thinking about, hey, what's going to look good in this little thumbnail first and foremost, and we'll figure everything else out later.
Annie Modafferi: How important is it for a product to communicate what it is within just a few seconds? So online, when you're looking at a product, like what visual information needs to be communicated immediately?
Rhett Withey: It's probably everything, right? So like on a shelf, you get like three seconds. Online, you get less because someone is like scrolling with their thumb while half watching TV. The essential though is what it is, who makes it, why it's different, and in that order. Right? If someone has to zoom in to figure out, like, “Is this dish soap or is this hand soap?”
Annie Modafferi: Yeah.
Rhett Withey: You've already lost them to the brand that just says dish soap in large, not glamorous letters.
Annie Modafferi: So do you think that consumers are really just looking for, “I need dish soap” instead of “This dish soap looks pretty?” Like a psychological question here. Do you believe we are more naturally drawn to the thing that looks the easiest, just the plain blue dish soap instead of the one that says like dish soap with flowers on it? That's a dollar more.
Rhett Withey: I think it's a feeling though, like dish soap. I don't really care, you know, what the bottle looks like, but I might care about my like- shampoos for my hair or body wash, right? They could be the exact same product inside, but if the packaging looks a little nicer, I'm thinking, “You know what? I deserve this.”
Annie Modafferi: Yeah, for sure. Especially with shampoo and dish soap. Do you think good product design is something consumers notice consciously, or is it more, like you said, about creating that immediate feeling and that they necessarily don't think about? So do you ever find yourself noticing that you do that, like you pick something prettier over something that looks a little more plain, or is that not, you think that's not everybody's case?
Rhett Withey: I'm an outlier for this because I do notice everything, but like good design is a bit like good plumbing. Okay. Nobody thinks about the plumbing in the house until it's bad. People don't walk away from a product saying like, “Wow, that was a really nice use of hierarchy and white space.” They say, “This one looks better” or “This feels more expensive.” And then they can't really explain why. That's the goal though. If someone is consciously noticing or notices the design, then it's either really exceptional or something's gone really wrong. And most of the time, I'm aiming for they bought it and didn't think twice about it.
Annie Modafferi: Okay. After working in product design, has the way you shopped changed? Do you find yourself looking at packaging differently than how you did before you became a designer?
Rhett Withey: It has completely ruined my life when it comes to shopping anywhere online or in store. Like I'll stop and look at a package of broccoli and I'm like, I have no, I'm not trying to buy broccoli, but look how they package broccoli. This is really interesting. Or flip side, like who the hell approved this gradient? Look at this drop shadow. This looks awful. And yes, I have absolutely bought products that I did not intend to buy solely because the packaging looked really nice and really well done, which is exactly the behavior that I'm paid to encourage. So at least I'm consistent there.
Annie Modafferi: And finally, as an intern myself, my second semester with Bigeye, do you have any advice for any interns like me, graphic design, not graphic design, anyone trying to go into the ad agency world that's currently in this job market, this state-of-the-world AI circulated, everything state-of-the-world coming in to the industry that we can leave off on today?
Rhett Withey: Well, I will say that in the couple decades that I've been doing this, or close to a couple decades that I've been doing this, I've heard everything from like, “This next thing is going to take over all of advertising”, and then that thing fades out in six months. I've heard that print design is dead forever. And you know what? Things are still getting printed in boxes. Things are still being printed on bottles. So as far as the AI stuff, I don't think that you necessarily need to be afraid of it for now. Because like I said, print was supposed to be dead 20 years ago and we're still here. So it just morphs and it just changes. So just be moldable and whatever you've learned in school will be completely different, uh, two years out of school. So just be able to go with the flow and stay current on things and you'll be fine.
Annie Modafferi: Alright, Rhett, thank you so much for being this week's guest on IN CLEAR FOCUS.
Rhett Withey: Thanks. Appreciate it. It was fun.
Annie Modafferi: Thanks again to my guest this week, Rhett Withey. As always, you'll find the complete transcript of our conversation with timestamps and links to the resources we discussed on the IN CLEAR FOCUS page at bigeyeagency.com. Thank you for listening to IN CLEAR FOCUS, produced by Bigeye. I've been this week's special host, Annie Modafferi. Until next time.
Timestamps
00:00: Introduction to Product Design
01:12: The Design Process Explained
02:57: Client Collaboration and Disagreements
04:26: Behind-the-Scenes Considerations
05:21: Balancing Functionality and Appeal
06:47: Design Trends and Longevity
08:12: Understanding Consumer Behavior
09:45: E-commerce vs. Retail Design
11:12: The Importance of Visual Communication
12:14: Retail Display Considerations
14:25: Designing for Online Platforms
16:21: Immediate Visual Information Needs
18:02: The Impact of Good Design on Shopping
19:53: Advice for Interns in the Industry
20:55: Conclusion and Wrap-Up





