
Bigeye's November 11, 2026 observation of 401 Amazon.com and Walmart.com listings found that prebiotic and fiber sodas sold at a median $0.18 a fluid ounce in Amazon's top 50 soft drinks, about 3.4 times the $0.05 median of the other 41. Premiumization in food and beverage now works only where the shopper can name what the extra money buys, and that list got shorter in 2026. Bigeye, the Orlando agency for consumer brands, plans pricing, packs and media for brands as a food and beverage marketing partner, and this guide is built on its WORTH IT. study.
Key takeaways
Bigeye found that prebiotic and fiber sodas held 9 of Amazon's top 50 soft drink spots at about 3.4 times the price per ounce of the rest, while Pepsi Prebiotic Cola ranked #30 at $0.07 an ounce.
Bigeye found that every priced jerky listing in Amazon's top 50 said protein, so protein no longer set the price. Zero or no-added-sugar copy did: a median $2.00 an ounce against $1.22.
NIQ reported that functional-beverage buyers each bought 8.8% more units over 52 weeks to April 18, 2026, against 1.5% for all beverages.
Shoppers still pay more for a short list. NCBA's analysis of Circana data shows beef up 5.7% a pound and pounds sold still up 2.1%.
Store brands took 23.7% of units in the year to Nov 1, 2026 (PLMA, Circana data). A premium line that can't explain itself loses to the shelf next to it.
What is premiumization?
Premiumization is the move to sell a higher priced version of a product by giving shoppers a reason to pay more: a function, an ingredient, a format, a claim or an experience. In food and beverage, it works when the reason is specific and visible on the pack or listing, and fails when the premium is only a price.
The numbers to plan around
Measure | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
US food spending, 2025 | $2.51 trillion | |
Food at home spending growth, 2025 | +2.8% (+0.6% price adjusted) | |
Food and beverage units, 4 weeks to Aug 29, 2026 | -1.8% (dollars +0.2%) | |
Units per functional-beverage buyer, 52 weeks to Apr 18, 2026 | +8.8% (all beverages +1.5%) | |
Beef price a pound / pounds sold, 52 weeks to Oct 4, 2026 | +5.7% / +2.1% | |
Store brand share of units, year to Nov 1, 2026 | 23.7% | |
Prebiotic soda price per ounce vs other top 50 soft drinks, Amazon | About 3.4 times ($0.18 vs $0.05) | |
Amazon jerky median per ounce, sugar claim vs none | $2.00 vs $1.22 | |
Amazon energy drink median per ounce, zero or low sugar vs none | $0.16 vs $0.11 | |
Quick-service traffic, Q3 2026 | -2.6% (average price +2.6%) |
Step 1: Find the one reason your shopper pays more
A premium needs one reason a shopper can repeat in a few words, such as gut health, no added sugar or grass fed. Start by listing what your buyers already pay extra for in your aisle, then pick the single benefit your product delivers better than the store brand beside it. Everything else on the pack supports that one reason.
The 2026 data shows how narrow the list is. Shoppers bought fewer grocery units overall, yet NIQ found functional-beverage buyers each bought 8.8% more units, and beef sold more pounds at a higher price. Both have a benefit people can name. A "premium" line built on vague quality words has nothing to point to.
Step 2: Check whether the claim still sets the price
A claim stops earning a premium once every competitor prints it. Before you build a price on a claim, pull the top 50 listings in your category on Amazon and Walmart.com and count how many already make it. If most do, the claim is the price of entry, and you need a second, rarer one to justify paying more.
Bigeye's jerky count shows this plainly. Protein appeared on 47 of 47 priced Amazon listings and 32 of 40 at Walmart.com, so it didn't separate anything. The listings with zero or no-added-sugar copy did, at a median $2.00 an ounce against $1.22. Energy drinks are heading the same way: zero or low sugar showed on 38 of 44 priced Amazon listings.
Step 3: Price the premium against the shelf, not your cost
Set the premium by what sits next to you on the shelf and in search results, not by your cost plus margin. Work out the price per ounce for your product, the leading national brand and the store brand, then decide how wide a gap your one reason can carry. Shoppers compare per ounce, so you should too.
Walmart.com shows how wide the gap already is in staple aisles. Bigeye found Great Value soda at a median $0.024 a fluid ounce against $0.048 for national brands. Store brands took 23.7% of units in the year to Nov 1, 2026, per PLMA's analysis of Circana data. A premium has to clear both of those prices in the shopper's head.
Step 4: Build a pack ladder so the shopper can trade up
A pack ladder gives the same product at several price points, so a shopper can try it at a low entry price and trade up when it earns a place in the basket. Plan a trial size, a core size and a multipack, and price each so the step up feels like a better deal, not a bigger bill.
Restaurants show the same pattern. Revenue Management Solutions reported quick-service traffic down 2.6% in Q3 2026, yet Burger King grew US comps 8.4% and Starbucks company-operated stores grew 7.7%, each with a low entry price and an add-on. Josh Kobza, CEO of Restaurant Brands International, said their "$5 Duos and $7 Trios continue to support steady value incidents as we see outsized growth in more premium areas of the menu." See Bigeye's packaging design work for how a ladder reads on shelf.
Step 5: Make the listing prove the premium
On Amazon and Walmart.com, the listing is where a shopper decides whether the extra cost is fair. Put the one reason in the title, the first image and the first bullet, and show the price per ounce comparison yourself if it helps your case. A premium the shopper has to dig for reads as a markup.
The prebiotic soda shelf shows the risk. Bigeye found 9 of Amazon's top 50 soft drinks carried a prebiotic or fiber claim at a median $0.18 a fluid ounce, while Pepsi Prebiotic Cola sat at #30 at $0.07. Once a national brand sells the same claim near regular soda prices, the premium players need a reason beyond the word prebiotic. Bigeye's shopper marketing guide covers how to plan that retailer by retailer.
Step 6: Spend retail media where the premium buyer shops
Retail media for a premium line should target the shoppers already buying the benefit, not everyone in the aisle. Use retailer audiences for buyers of functional, organic or no-sugar products, bid on the claim terms they search, and judge the campaign on repeat purchase, since a premium only pays off on the second order.
Grocery dollars are moving toward mass and club. Numerator put Walmart's grocery dollar share at 20.3% and Costco's at 8.4% for the 12 months to Sept 30, 2026, both up. That's where the premium buyer is comparing prices. Bigeye's Walmart Connect guide covers how to buy against Walmart's own store brands.
Step 7: Plan budgets on units, not dollars
When prices rise, dollar sales can grow while fewer people buy. Set targets on units and households for a premium line, and treat dollar growth as a result rather than the goal. A forecast built on price-inflated dollars will hide a line that's losing buyers until it's too late to fix.
Circana's late summer read shows the gap: food and beverage dollars up 0.2% and units down 1.8% in the 4 weeks to August 29, 2026. USDA put 2025 food at home spending up 2.8%, but only 0.6% once price changes are taken out. Bigeye's marketing budget allocation guide shows how to split spend once the unit targets are set.
Where each premium lever works
Lever | Best for | Watch |
|---|---|---|
Functional claim | Beverages, snacks, supplements | Claim spreading to national brands |
Sugar claim | Jerky, energy drinks, kids drinks | Proof on the pack and listing |
Pack ladder | Restaurants, beverages, snacks | Value size undercutting the core |
Origin or quality | Beef, juice, coffee | Price gap against store brands |
What it looks like in practice
Bigeye's work for the National Mango Board lifted website visits 23%, paid social 275%, display 647% and video 726%. The lesson carries to premium food and beverage lines: give shoppers a specific reason to choose the product, then put that reason in every channel they see.
Bigeye's read
Most food and beverage brands should stop launching "premium" lines and start launching "proven" ones. If you can't name the one claim that sets your price, and show that fewer than half of the top 50 listings in your aisle make it, you don't have a premium product. You have a more expensive one, and store brands at 23.7% of units are waiting for it.
How Bigeye helps
Bigeye helps food and beverage brands find the one reason shoppers will pay more, then build the pack, the listing and the retail media plan around it, as a CPG marketing agency working across Amazon, Walmart and grocery. Its WORTH IT. study tracked 401 listings to see which claims still set the price. Talk to Bigeye about your 2027 pricing and pack plan.
"There's so many discounts throughout the year. And I don't know about you, but five years ago, Memorial Day was a 20% discount. Nowadays, Prime Day is a 20% discount. And so to me, it's just, it's not meaningful."
Nik Hall, Founder and CEO, REViVE Marketing Partners, on IN CLEAR FOCUS
Frequently asked questions
What is premiumization in food and beverage?
Premiumization is selling a higher priced version of a food or drink by giving shoppers a reason to pay more, such as a function, ingredient or format. Bigeye's WORTH IT. study shows it works in 2026 only where the reason is specific, like prebiotic sodas at about 3.4 times the price per ounce.
Are shoppers still paying more for premium food in 2026?
Yes, for a short list. NCBA's analysis of Circana data shows beef up 5.7% a pound while pounds sold rose 2.1%, and NIQ found functional-beverage buyers each bought 8.8% more units. Overall units fell, so the premium only holds where shoppers can name what it buys.
How do store brands affect a premium pricing strategy?
Store brands set the floor a premium has to clear. PLMA's analysis of Circana data put store brands at 23.7% of units in the year to Nov 1, 2026. Bigeye found Great Value soda at $0.024 an ounce on Walmart.com, half the national brand median, so the premium must be visible.
Does a protein claim still justify a higher price?
In jerky, no. Bigeye's Amazon count found protein on all 47 priced top 50 listings, so it no longer separated anything. Zero or no-added-sugar copy did, at a median $2.00 an ounce against $1.22. Check how many competitors share a claim before you build a price on it.
How should a premium food brand use retail media?
Target shoppers already buying the benefit, such as functional or no-sugar products, and bid on the claim terms they search. Judge campaigns on repeat purchase, not the first order. Walmart held 20.3% of US grocery dollars in Numerator's data, so it's where most premium buyers compare prices.
Start the conversation
If your next line needs to earn its price, Bigeye can help you test the claim, build the pack ladder and plan the media. See Bigeye's food and beverage marketing work or start the conversation.
Sources: Bigeye, WORTH IT. study and Amazon.com and Walmart.com observation, Nov 11, 2026; USDA Economic Research Service, 2025 food spending; Circana, 4 weeks to Aug 29, 2026; NIQ Expanded Omnishopper, 52 weeks to Apr 18, 2026; NCBA analysis of Circana data, 52 weeks to Oct 4, 2026; PLMA, Circana data, year to Nov 1, 2026; Numerator, 12 months to Sept 30, 2026; Revenue Management Solutions, Q3 2026; Restaurant Brands International and Starbucks Q3 2026 results; IN CLEAR FOCUS; National Mango Board case study.




